100 Years Ago Today - Czar Nicholas and Family Murdered

Peter_Suciu

Well-known member
In Yekaterinburg, Russia, Czar Nicholas II and his family were executed by the Bolsheviks on July 16, 1918, bringing an end to the three-century-old Romanov dynasty.

Crowned in 1896, Nicholas was neither trained nor inclined to rule, which did not help the autocracy he sought to preserve among a people desperate for change. The disastrous outcome of the Russo-Japanese War led to the Russian Revolution of 1905, which ended only after Nicholas approved a representative assembly–the Duma–and promised constitutional reforms. The czar soon retracted these concessions and repeatedly dissolved the Duma when it opposed him, contributing to the growing public support for the Bolsheviks and other revolutionary groups. In 1914, Nicholas led his country into another costly war–World War I–that Russia was ill-prepared to win. Discontent grew as food became scarce, soldiers became war weary and devastating defeats at the hands of Germany demonstrated the ineffectiveness of Russia under Nicholas.

In March 1917, revolution broke out on the streets of Petrograd (now St. Petersburg) and Nicholas was forced to abdicate his throne later that month. That November, the radical socialist Bolsheviks, led by Vladimir Lenin, seized power in Russia from the provisional government, sued for peace with the Central Powers and set about establishing the world’s first communist state. Civil war broke out in Russia in June 1918, and in July the anti-Bolshevik “White” Russian forces advanced on Yekaterinburg, where Nicholas and his family were located, during a campaign against the Bolshevik forces. Local authorities were ordered to prevent a rescue of the Romanovs, and after a secret meeting of the Yekaterinburg Soviet, a death sentence was passed on the imperial family.

Late on the night of July 16, Nicholas, Alexandra, their five children and four servants were ordered to dress quickly and go down to the cellar of the house in which they were being held. There, the family and servants were arranged in two rows for a photograph they were told was being taken to quell rumors that they had escaped. Suddenly, a dozen armed men burst into the room and gunned down the imperial family in a hail of gunfire. Those who were still breathing when the smoked cleared were stabbed to death.

The remains of Nicholas, Alexandra and three of their children were excavated in a forest near Yekaterinburg in 1991 and positively identified two years later using DNA fingerprinting. The Crown Prince Alexei and one Romanov daughter were not accounted for, fueling the persistent legend that Anastasia, the youngest Romanov daughter, had survived the execution of her family. Of the several “Anastasias” that surfaced in Europe in the decade after the Russian Revolution, Anna Anderson, who died in the United States in 1984, was the most convincing. In 1994, however, scientists used DNA to prove that Anna Anderson was not the czar’s daughter but a Polish woman named Franziska Schanzkowska.
 
A really sad story ... especially because the english crown has planned a secrect escape of the tsar and his family. Today the russian crowd wishes the monarchy back and the double headed crowned eagle adorns again the presidental flag with proud.
I would wish the same proud of our monachical history for Germany, but Wilhelm II. is for many germans still the main responsible of the World War One and imperial Germany is considered as a previous version of Nazi-Germany (even though scientific opinion has revised this by now).
 
Sandmann said:
A really sad story ... especially because the english crown has planned a secrect escape of the tsar and his family.

I think IF King George V and the government in London knew that the Czar would be killed they might have accepted them into exile. In 1917 with Ireland still in turmoil following the 1916 Easter Rebellion and worries of strikes at home the British government knew bringing the Czar to England could be a problem. There were serious worries about the spread of revolution.

So the Romanov's were killed and with it came 70 years of Communism that spread across Russia and Eastern Europe. It still lives on China, but in the end capitalism is winning!
 
All the Russian Revolution did was replace one corrupt ruling elite with yet another at the cost of millions of Russian and other people’s lives. Unfortunately, the Russian people have never known anything but dictatorship in one form or another.
 
ebeeby said:
Sadly, the scourge of Leninism/Marxism lives (increasingly) on in the American Left.

On account of there being no such thing as the American "left", I can reassure you that you will be spared the "scourge of Leninism/Marxism" :p
 
Yes, no such thing as L/M exists anymore, long gone (1924) and replaced by pure realistic, good old fashioned dictatorship. As a Historian, I loved the recent pic of Putin riding bare chested on horseback. Look up a guy called Mussolini, I think he was Italian and you will see him in the same propaganda picture from the 1920’s. That's what dictators do, they have to look tough and manly! As an aside, I wasn't quite as impressed by Putin's "Man vs Fish" pic where he is seen wrestling with a big Russian Pike he caught, I love the big white horse much better....just my opinion. Damn...another F...ing Historical thought.... is there not another famous painting out there, of a little French Dude (big sword) dressed in a fancy uniform riding a big white horse on some mountain trail?? What is it with this big white horse thing???
All part of the human comedy that we seem to be condemned to repeat generation after generation. A thought....perhaps, this is all part of God's or Nature's plan for population control? I mean the little dictators kill off a minimum of a thousand humans in their elimination of their/the people's enemies BUT the really successful guys like Stalin, Hitler and Mao kill off millions. Hitler gets all the press but good old "Uncle Joe" has him beat by millions and I am not talking soldier deaths but unarmed civilians. Not sure whether Vlad has killed off his first thousand yet???
 
This kind of discussion really has no place on the forum, but as the site admin is one of the responsible parties I guess I will not moderate it. I find in interesting how Trump (who is with out question an ass) is criticized by the world while the man who was instrumental in creating the world's worst humanitarian crisis is praised and held up as a great leader
 
Gustaf said:
This kind of discussion really has no place on the forum, but as the site admin is one of the responsible parties I guess I will not moderate it. I find in interesting how Trump (who is with out question an ass) is criticized by the world while the man who was instrumental in creating the world's worst humanitarian crisis is praised and held up as a great leader
I apologize to all if my comment was against the Forum-Rulez. I didn‘t want to crash the Post and didn’t want to offend anyone here in the Forum.
 
As I often say, "politics and religion aren't something to discuss amongst friends -- really because you are all wrong!"
 
I have removed my golf cart post as it was over the top and off topic. I have PM'd Sandy and asked permission to delete his 2 posts.
 
b.loree said:
I have removed my golf cart post as it was over the top and off topic. I have PM'd Sandy and asked permission to delete his 2 posts.

Hello Brian,
did you receive my PM? I’m not sure if it has been sent because it is still in Outbox but marked as „sent“.
You may delete the mentioned posts incouding this one.
Thank you in advance.
 
Back
Top