Wagner Silver-Gilt Pour le Mérite

Lost Skeleton

Active member
I haven't actively been collecting Imperial German awards for some time, but this proved an exception. After years of settling for gap-filler, postwar Zweitstück PLMs that run the gamut from sanctioned to schmuck, I finally landed a textbook wartime Wagner (with Eichenlaub, no less). Ignore the case, which is merely a repro for storage. As with all late war silver-gilt PLMs, the cross is solid .938 silver and proofed as such on the lower arm. The oakleaves are .800 silver. It's not perfect – the enamel is chipped below the "Po" in Pour – but the wear and tear is honest:

Wagner Silver-Gilt 1.jpg

.938 silver and W (for Wagner, Berlin):

Wagner Silver-Gilt 3.jpg

.800 silver proof on the Eichenlaub suspension ring:

Wagner Silver-Gilt 4.jpg

The eagles tell the story – nothing postwar can match their detail:

Wagner Silver-Gilt 2.jpg

For comparison, I refer to the below as an "After Wagner." Though the eagles are a rough approximation of the Wagner style, the beaks are not open and the detail is poor. Still, from a social distance, it is reasonably convincing. This unmarked PLM copy was purchased by its previous owner in England in 1948:

After Wagner.jpg

My other unofficial/postwar crosses:

First, a C. F. Rothe & Neffe, Wien. These were produced from the Weimar Era through 1970s. The more recent Rothe PLMs were merely for the collector market. Older crosses, like this one, feature a deeper blue enamel. The lettering is chase-engraved and the eagles applied individually. The suspension ring is marked .800:

C.F. Rothe & Neffe 1.jpg

C.F. Rothe & Neffe 2.jpg

Otto Schickle, Pforzheim: This is my favorite 3rd Reich Era (LDO L/15) private purchase PLM. The design is quite similar to earlier Godet private purchase crosses:

Otto Schickle Pforzheim.jpg

A Schickle variant illustrated in the firm's catalogue:

Otto Schickle Catalogue 1.JPG

Finally, Steinhauer & Lück, Ludensheid. Another 3rd Reich Manufacturer (LDO L/16), S&L PLMs enjoy a controversial status among collectors. The earliest S&Ls, like this one, are .800 silver-gilt. Later crosses are bronze-gilt, and, in my opinion, little more than mass-produced replicas. The archetypal S&L features eagles with crudely finished legs, and an "ur" in Pour connected by the respective serifs. In 1957, Steinhauer & Lück produced official "de-nazified" Wehrmacht awards and badges, and the firm exists well into the 21st century.

Steinhauer & Lück 1.jpg

Cheers!

Charles
 
Last edited:

Lost Skeleton

Active member
Thank you one and all for the kind words.

Brian, I see the forum has a new look. I will have to learn my way around the manor anew. I have two more photos to share – portraits of Ernst Jünger, the last living recipient of the Pour le Mérite.

In advanced years he wears what I believe to be a Steinhauer & Lück Zweitstuck with the 50 year jubilee crown. It is certainly not the same PLM as in the wartime photo:valor-960x640.jpgim18c2_kl1.jpg
 
Last edited:

b.loree

Administrator
Staff member
Yes Chas, we have entered the 21st C at last :) . It is actually much easier to post and get around the forum now. Naturally, I have read "Storm of Steel" but I have never seen either of these two photos before. Thanks for posting these.
 

JohnS3rd

Active member
Charles,
Thank you for this fantastic primer on the PLM and its variants. Your pictures of the details are a great addition to a discussion on this award.
Cheers
John
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Steve Nick

Active member
Charles:

Great post!

Thanks for posting those detailed photos and the accompanying text.

I've always thought I'd like to have a PLM in my collection. Now that I'm collecting in a more eclectic fashion, I'll be paying more attention to the details in the hope of finding one in future.

Love the pictures of Herr Jünger. New to me as well.
 
Top